Skip Nav

Sorry, Donald Trump. Term limits for Congress are (probably) never, ever going to happen.

Navigation menu

❶As early as the Delaware constitution established a two-term limit for the governor, and nearly four fifths of the states now place some sort of restriction on the number of terms for which an individual may hold the governorship.

Learn more about Term Limits

The arguments against term limits
Choose a demographic filter
Report Abuse

Governors exert more influence over crafting state budgets once limits are imposed, and legislators spend less time on oversight of the executive branch. In many states as in the federal government , the chief executive also faces term limits. Since the ratification of the Twenty-second Amendment in , U. Such limits have been motivated less by the desire to bring new perspectives into office and more by concerns about halting the accumulation of power over time into the hands of a single leader.

The Twenty-second Amendment was proposed by a Republican Congress not long after Democrat Franklin Delano Roosevelt — had won his fourth term. The amendment was proposed in order to prevent similarly popular future presidents from holding the office for life. Enacted for similar reasons, term limits on governors have had less profound effects than limits on legislators because they rarely bring political newcomers into office and serve to solidify rather than disrupt the normal rate of turnover.

In American statehouses, by contrast, term limits do much to shape the legislative landscape. It appears term limits will be a permanent feature of state political life since the courts have affirmed term limits in principle in the Bates v. Jones decision and most attempts to repeal or relax limits have met with staunch public opposition. The spread of term limits across the nation has also apparently come to a stop because they have been passed in nearly every state with an initiative process and the courts have made it clear that states cannot impose term limits on their members of Congress in U.

This leaves the nation in the midst of a large-scale experiment with a central rule of democracy. Approximately a third of state legislatures operate under the same sorts of limits that were imposed under the Articles of Confederation , while two-thirds follow the guidance of the Constitutional Convention to leave legislators unhindered.

The coming decades will test the wisdom of each system. Institutional Change in American Politics: The Case of Term Limits. University of Michigan Press. Term Limits and Legislative Representation. Niemi, and Lynda W. Term Limits in the State Legislatures. Term Limits in the State Legislatures: Results from a New Survey of the 50 States. National Conference of State Legislatures. Legislative Term Limits Overview. The History of an Idea. In Limiting Legislative Terms , eds.

Gerald Benjamin and Michael Malbin. The Yale Law Journal Cite this article Pick a style below, and copy the text for your bibliography.

Retrieved September 14, from Encyclopedia. Then, copy and paste the text into your bibliography or works cited list. Because each style has its own formatting nuances that evolve over time and not all information is available for every reference entry or article, Encyclopedia.

Focusing especially on members of the U. Congress, term limits became an important national political issue during the late s and early 90s and have been vigorously debated.

Proponents, who include a large cross section of the American public, feel that a limitation on the period of time a politician may hold office reduces abuses of power and the concentration on reelection by entrenched incumbents, encourages political participation by nonpoliticians, and makes government more responsive to public needs. Opponents maintain that elections already serve as a built-in way of providing term limits, feel that such limits are unconstitutional and undemocratic, and cite the benefits of seniority and of the experience conferred by years in office.

Many proponents have called for a constitutional amendment similar to the 22d Amendment , which limits the president's tenure, to set national term limits. Gubernatorial term limits are the oldest and most common U. As early as the Delaware constitution established a two-term limit for the governor, and nearly four fifths of the states now place some sort of restriction on the number of terms for which an individual may hold the governorship.

Legislative term limits are of more recent origin. From to a total of 19 states set term limits for state legislators, to take effect variously between and Terms limits on state legislators were subsequently overturned for technical reasons in Oregon, and repealed by the legislature in Idaho.

Twenty-one states approved term limits on members of the U. State term limits on federal legislators were challenged in the courts, and in the U. Supreme Court narrowly ruled that states could not impose them and only a constitutional amendment could assure them. There really hasn't been a major push for term limits since. Some lawmakers have decided to impose their own term limits. But history is littered with broken term-limit promises.

But in , he was back, saying the idea of term limits is flawed unless everyone agrees to them. We're picking on Salmon, but lots of lawmakers have and continue to run for office despite making campaign pledges to leave office at a certain date. In other words, proposing term limits for Congress is a popular thing to say on the campaign trail. And of all the reasons Trump's term-limit proposal won't happen, this is probably the most salient: Congress doesn't want it.

Term limits for Congress are probably never, ever going to happen. During a rally in Colorado, Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump pledged to introduce a constitutional amendment that would impose term limits on members of Congress.

The story must be told. Bitter Senate fight to confirm Kavanaugh plunges deeper into chaos over letter. Analysis Winners and losers of the primary season. The practice of nomination rotation for the House of Representatives began to decline after the Civil War. It took a generation or so before the direct primary system, civil service reforms, and the ethic of professionalism worked to eliminate rotation in office as a common political practice.

By the turn of the 20th century the era of incumbency was coming into full swing. A total of 8 presidents served two full terms and declined a third and three presidents served one full term and refused a second. After World War II , however, an officeholder class had developed to the point that congressional tenure rivaled that of the U. Supreme Court , where tenure is for life.

The concept of homesteading brought about a popular movement known as the "term-limits movement". The elections of —94 saw the adoption of term limits for state legislatures in almost every state where citizens had the power of the initiative. In addition, 23 states limited service in their delegation to Congress. As they pertain to Congress, these laws are no longer enforceable, however, as in , the U. Supreme Court overturned congressional term limits in U.

Thornton , ruling that state governments cannot limit the terms of members of the national government. Where rotation in the legislative branch has withstood court challenges, term limits continue to garner popular support. As of , the advocacy group " U.

Term Limits " found that in the 17 states where state legislators served in rotation, public support for term limits ranged from 60 to 78 percent.

As of , term limits at the federal level are restricted to the executive branch and some agencies. Judicial appointments at the federal level are made for life, and are not subject to election or to term limits. Congress remains since the Thornton decision of without electoral limits. The short-lived Confederate States of America adopted a six-year term for their president and vice-president and barred the president from seeking re-election. That innovation was endorsed by many American politicians after the American Civil War , most notably by Rutherford B.

Hayes in his inaugural address. Roosevelt president, — was the first and only U. He died in office a few months after starting his fourth term. This gave rise to a successful move in Congress to formalize the traditional two-term limit by amending the U. As ratified in , the Twenty-Second Amendment provides that "no person shall be elected to the office of President more than twice". Reformers during the early s used the initiative and referendum to put congressional term limits on the ballot in 24 states.

Voters in eight of these states approved the congressional term limits by an average electoral margin of two to one. In May , the U. Supreme Court ruled 5—4 in U. Thornton , U. In the elections, part of the Republican platform included legislation for term limits in Congress.

After winning the majority, a Republican congressman brought a constitutional amendment to the House floor that proposed limiting members of the Senate to two six-year terms and members of the House to six two-year terms.

Term Limits , the largest private organization pushing for congressional term limits. Defeated in Congress and overridden by the Supreme Court, the federal term limit uprising was brought to a halt.

The term limits intended simultaneously to reform state legislatures as distinguished from the federal congressional delegations remain in force, however, in fifteen states. In Larry J. Sabato revived the debate over term limits by arguing in A More Perfect Constitution that the success and popularity of term limits at the state level suggests that they should be adopted at the federal level as well. He specifically put forth the idea of congressional term limits and suggested a national constitutional convention be used to accomplish the amendment, since the Congress would be unlikely to propose and adopt any amendment that limits its own power.

Some state legislators have also expressed their opinions on term limits. It is confirmed that in the following five states—and there may be others—state lawmakers approved resolutions asking Congress to propose a federal constitutional amendment to limit the number of terms which members of Congress may serve:. Legal scholars have discussed whether or not to impose term limits on the Supreme Court of the United States.

Currently, Supreme Court Justices are appointed for life "during good behavior". A sentiment has developed, among certain scholars, that the Supreme Court may not be accountable in a way that is most in line with the spirit of checks and balances. Calebresi and James Lindgren, professors of law at Northwestern University, argued that, because vacancies in the court are occurring with less frequency and justices served on average, between and , for Many of the proposals center around a term limit for Justices that would be 18 years Larry Sabato, Professor of Political Science at University of Virginia, suggested between 15 and 18 years.

Calebresi, Lingren, and Carrington have also proposed that when justices have served out their proposed year term they should be able to sit on other Federal Courts until retirement, death, or removal. Some state lawmakers have officially expressed to Congress a desire for a federal constitutional amendment to limit terms of Supreme Court justices as well as of judges of federal courts below the Supreme Court level.

While there might be others, below are three known examples:. Term limits for state officials have existed since colonial times. The Pennsylvania Charter of Liberties of , and the colonial frame of government of the same year, both authored by William Penn , provided for triennial rotation of the provincial council —the upper house of the colonial legislature.

At present, 36 states have term limits of various types for their governors. To circumvent the term limit in Alabama incumbent governor George Wallace pushed through the nomination of his wife Lurleen , in the Democratic primary, which was, in those days, the real contest in Alabama. It was generally understood that Mrs. Wallace would only be a titular governor while her husband continued to hold the real power.

She won the election, but only served 16 months before dying in As indicated above, in fifteen state legislatures the members serve in rotation, i. In another six states, however, state legislatures have either overturned their own limits or state supreme courts have ruled such limits unconstitutional. In the Idaho Legislature became the first legislature of its kind to repeal its own term limits, enacted by a public vote in , ostensibly because it applied to local officials along with the legislature.

Governors of 36 states and four territories are subject to various term limits, while the governors of 14 states, Puerto Rico , and the Mayor of Washington, D. Each state's gubernatorial term limits are prescribed by its state constitution , with the exception of Wyoming , whose limits are found in its statutes. Virgin Islands , and by statute in American Samoa. Unique in its restriction, Virginia prohibits its governors from succeeding themselves for a second term, although former governors are reeligible after four years out of office.

Arguments for term limits

Main Topics

Privacy Policy

Twenty years after the Supreme Court, in a poorly reasoned 5–4 decision, stymied the movement to enact congressional term limits via state ballot initiatives, term limits advocates are stuck trying to convince two-thirds of the members in each house of Congress to pass an amendment to the Constitution which would effectively kick them out of office.

Privacy FAQs

Term limits are unconstitutional. Clearly this is not the case, as the President of the United States is limited to two terms because of a Constitutional Amendment. A 28th Amendment would be necessary to impose term limits for Congress, and that is precisely what we are seeking.

About Our Ads

Twenty years after the Supreme Court, in a poorly reasoned decision, stymied the movement to enact congressional term limits via state ballot initiatives, term limits advocates are stuck trying to convince two-thirds of the members in each house of Congress to pass an amendment to the Constitution which would effectively kick them out of office. Term limits in the United States apply to many offices at both the federal and state level, and date back to the American Revolution.. Term limits, also referred to as rotation in office, restrict the number of terms of office an officeholder may hold.

Cookie Info

Nov 20,  · Resolved: Congressional term limits should be enacted. You have completed research establishing three arguments for term limits and three arguments against them. Now you must take a side! I need at least three arguments for congressional term limits and three arguments against them. Please help!Status: Resolved. In reality, there is almost no possibility that congressional term limits will be enacted. In the past, some states attempted to impose term limits on their congressional delegations in .